top of page
  • Grey Instagram Icon
  • Grey Facebook Icon
  • Grey Pinterest Icon
  • Grey Twitter Icon
  • Grey YouTube Icon
Search

Removed

  • Writer: Aleeya Consul
    Aleeya Consul
  • Jan 10, 2019
  • 3 min read

Updated: Jan 15, 2019

A connection between a novel and a television show that has similarities between being "removed" from the normal world.


Hello again, this is my second blog post. You will read about the connection between Station Eleven and The Handmaid's Tale.


"Removed"

It is apparent that the novel, Station Eleven, written by Emily St. John Mandel is considered a dystopian genre as it talks about a post collapse that occurs after a world-wide pandemic. The word ‘dystopian’ can be described as “an imagined state or society where there is great suffering or injustice”. When reading this book, the world has “so-on-so ended” creating the minimal survivors to reconstruct a new way of survival. This post collapse enforces people to act with their primal instincts, and where there is no real hierarchy at first, it creates one man to become greedy and want to be known as the “prophet”. The prophet becomes this man of power having authority of the many followers he recruits and of course, whenever there is an authority, there are also people who are against what they stand for. Meaning the prophet cannot control every single person left on the earth.


These overall aspects of a dystopian genre, surviving, and authority over others, are features that reminded myself of a television show I binged watched over the summer. From text to media, I can connect Station Eleven to the show, The Handmaid’s Tale.


Like Station Eleven, The Handmaid’s Tale is based on a dystopian city named Gilead that is separated from the rest of the world. Gilead is located in the United States but is still isolated from modern normal society. This show is about the different rich families that take advantage of fertile woman from the outside world and kidnap them to become handmaids for the rich who have infertile wives. With this, these handmaid’s are taken away from their own families and potentially become abused to bear a child for the rich. After the nine months they are impregnated, the baby gets rip from their arms and again the cycle begins and they are reassigned to a new family, weeks after.


In relation to the novel and the show, both worlds are “removed” and taken away from the lives they were once used to and must fight in order to survive. Survival in Station Eleven, is seen when a character must kill an opposing threat to keep living, similar to the show, where the handmaids must obey their “masters” or there will be extreme consequences.

Another aspect that connects this text to this media, is that there are both figures of authority that abuse the power they hold. The common theme of abuse of woman is seen in both instances as the prophet literally takes women and girls to wed, and the rich, kidnap women to impregnate. Additional to these men with power, in Station Eleven, like Kirsten Raymonde, she is an individual who opposes what the prophet stands for and is there to fight and protect the people who she cares for. In The Handmaid’s Tale, there is also a strong female role named Offred that tries to stand up for her own rights unlike the other handmaids that are too afraid to, she even attempts multiple times to escape Gilead to reach Canada, which is a place where Gilead cannot touch.


All-in-all, the dystopian theme demonstrated in both the novel and the show are clear connections that can be made. To live in either worlds, they both hold the similarity to survive, which includes suppressing one’s past memories so that that character will not break down and only grow stronger in the end.


Additional Links


https://www.shortlist.com/news/20-best-dystopian-novels/43969


https://www.chapters.indigo.ca/en-ca/books/the-handmaids-tale/9780771008795-item.html


https://www.hulu.com/press/show/the-handmaids-tale/


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

4 Comments


Jason Lam
Jason Lam
Jan 17, 2019

I have never watched or read The Handmaid’s Tale, but you were able to explain it in a way that I was able to understand what it was about. Great explanation! I can see how both worlds in Station Eleven and The Handmaid’s Tale can be seen as “removed”, since both worlds that the characters are used to is replaced with a much worse, darker world. People emerge in the chaos and become figures of authority, however they abuse their power, such as the prophet in Station Eleven and the rich in The Handmaid’s Tale. It’s good that there are women in power in that are standing up and fighting against the abusive men; this shows that women are no…

Like

Toven Bella
Toven Bella
Jan 14, 2019

Good connection between Station Eleven and the show you watched. Even though I’ve never watched it before, you summarized it a point where I understand the plot. I agree that both worlds are “removed” and taken away from themselves. In Station 11, the previous world has disappeared and is waiting for another one to form. Both stories have a world that people wish was replaced with a better one. Also, the connection between Kirsten and Offred is strong as both possess a strong personality that drives their motivation. Women in the media and society overall are beginning to take on stronger roles as opposed to the men. I appreciate this gesture because women don’t have the same roles that the…

Like

Cassandra Poon
Cassandra Poon
Jan 14, 2019

I agree that The Handmaid's Tale and Station Eleven are both dystopian novels and have some similar concepts. As I have read Station Eleven and The Handmaid's Tale, I can see why they would be similar. I agree with your point that being "removed" is a big part of both stories. In both texts, something has happened to the world causing peoples' way of life needing to be changed. More specifically, something has happened to the human population causing people to need or want to take extreme measures. The world that we know as "normal" doesn't seem to be the "normal" anymore in these novels. The difference in these two stories would be that in Station Eleven, everyone has been…

Like

Jason Chan
Jason Chan
Jan 14, 2019

Nice post! I do see how the novel of Station Eleven and the show have the same theme of "dystopian". Station Eleven does have that "unwanted/undesired future" that is caused by the Georgia Flu. Station Eleven's world has not much of the "previous world" left. The technology is gone, there is no more internet, little to no communication left, no more literature being made and everything is really "removed". I can see the show "Handmaid's tale" can connect to Station Eleven. They both have a "unwanted" world that people in the stories do not really want/enjoy. Very interesting connection of the text, station eleven, to the show "Handmaid's Tale"

Like

SIGN UP FOR ALL UPDATES,

POSTS & NEWS

  • Grey Instagram Icon
  • Grey Facebook Icon
  • Grey Pinterest Icon
  • Grey Twitter Icon
  • Grey YouTube Icon

© 2023 by Shades of Pink. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page